Please give the proper reason with details in this question?

enter image source here

1 Answer
Jan 11, 2018

Well, in a dehydration reaction, remember that the betaβ hydrogen is removed along with the adjacent "OH"OH, but the base that acts actually approaches the betaβ hydrogen first, and the electrons flow towards the "OH"OH.

(3)(3) is quite hard; it is problematic in the same way as the right-hand betaβ hydrogen in (2)(2), combined with having no alkane betaβ hydrogens to the right of "OH"OH. It would either generate "C"="C"="C"C=C=C or a triple bond.


So the one that is hardest to dehydrate is the one that (i)(i) does not have a betaβ hydrogen, and/or (ii)(ii) would generate "C"="C"="C"C=C=C rather than conjugated piπ bonds.

  • (1)(1) could work just fine to generate a piπ bond adjacent to the "OH"OH; there are three betaβ hydrogens to its right.

  • (2)(2) is possible, but the two betaβ hydrogens to the left of the "OH"OH is preferentially chosen since forming "C"="C"="C"C=C=C (by choosing the right-hand betaβ hydrogen) is not as easy as forming conjugated piπ bonds.

  • (4)(4) is arguably the easiest, because it has four adjacent betaβ hydrogens, two on each side of the "OH"OH.