Why do we describe the "ELECTRONIC" geometry of the water molecule as tetrahedral, but its molecular geometry as bent?

1 Answer
Mar 20, 2017

"Well, there are 4 electron pairs around the central oxygen atom," "so.........."

Explanation:

There are 4 valence electron pairs in water: 2 bonding, the O-H bonds; and 2 non-bonding, the O lone pairs. VESPER dictates that the most stable geometry of these bonding and lone pairs is tetrahedral.

And thus to a first approximation, the /_H-O-H should be 109.5^@, which of course is the ideal tetrahedral angle - certainly this is the /_H-C-H bond angle we observe in methane.

However (and there is always a "however"), because TWO of the electron pairs around oxygen are LONE pairs, these tend to lie closer to the oxygen atom. And these lone pairs tend to compress the /_H-O-H bond angle down from the tetrahedral angle to approx. 104.5^@ by electrostatic repulsion of like charges. We may make the same argument for the ammonia molecule, NH_3, "trigonal pyramidal" BUT tetrahedral to a first approximation. Capisce?